The Netflix show’s third season hit the streaming platform on Thursday, June 5. During the finale, Georgia Miller (Brianne Howey) discovered that she’s pregnant for real after faking a pregnancy earlier in the season.

Whilst a lot of us are still coming to terms with the ending of Ginny and Georgia season three, it’s been revealed the show’s creators wrote an alternate conclusion. It would have changed everything.

Ultimately, there’s never peace for Ginny and Georgia, because season 3 ends on a cliffhanger: Georgia is pregnant. “I want people to finish the season and stand up as if they just got off a ride,” series creator Sarah Lampert told Today. “I want them to sound like lunatics trying to explain what just happened.”